TRENDING TOPICS

PINKWASHING

By Sumaya Mamdoo

Kering logo

This is an opinion piece and reflects the views of the author and not necessarily the views of Covered. I would also like to state that while I am not a member of the LGBTQIA+ community, I do consider myself an ally. This does mean that I am not fully qualified on having an opinion on this matter and would like for you to keep that in mind as you read. Thank you to my friends in the queer community for guiding me through writing this peace.

If you haven’t seen the Rainbow Pride Collection for sale at Woolworths, I’m sure you’ve seen the backlash and criticism against the South African retailer online. While we can all argue against the “Gay Agenda” and debate to the end of times about what is morally and religiously correct or not, let’s look at the capitalistic agenda first.
Pinkwashing is a term that is used to refer to manipulation tactics used by an establishment to portray themselves as liberal or very left-wing when that is not the case. There are two definitions of pinkwashing that can range from flat-out lying to using the LGBTQIA+ community for for-profit purposes.

A prime example of this is Israel Pride Week. This pride week takes place in June and has an attendance of 200 000 people where self-expression and queer culture is celebrated and promoted. This comes across as very progressive and fits into liberal movements of the West but runs in conjunction with the human rights abuses of the Palestinian people. Does this mean you can identify as anything except Palestinian?  The promotion of allyship by Israel serves as a propaganda tactic. Sometimes the IDF tweets pictures of soldiers supporting the queer community or women empowerment images, but they are the violent enforcers of an apartheid system. Israel also uses Palestinian homophobia to promote their occupation- by showing the world that Israel is superior and one of the reasons is Palestine’s treatment of homosexuals.
The second definition refers to corporate pinkwashing which is using the LGBTQIA+ cause as a marketing tool and nothing more. A large corporate company that will benefit from a small community but will not actually do anything to serve them. During pride month there is almost a rush for companies to run social media campaigns or feature a product in the rainbow colours of the pride flag. Red, orange, blue and all the other colours are plastered on spaces to acknowledge the month. It is beginning to come around like clockwork, like Christmas decorations everywhere.

Pride campaigns serve as a rainbow cog in the machine. Another way for corporates to make money and keep making money. An example of pinkwashing would be the pride campaign that BMW ran in 2022 where they changed their logo to feature the rainbow colours on social media accounts across the world, except in Russia, where homosexuality is outlawed. If they truly aligned and wanted to support the queer community, why not support Russia too? Were they too afraid of the backlash or too afraid of losing customers and money in that country?

Ultimately, from a demographic point of view, the LGBTQIA+ community can form a large part of customers. Although there are no official numbers (the South African census does not keep a record of gender identity or sexual orientation) according to this 2019 article, 634 000 South Africans would self-identify as members of the LGBTQIA+ community. Why not appeal to them?

So, what is the capitalistic-gay agenda?
The Woolworths collection features 6 items (t-shirts, socks, a tote, and a bucket hat) with the pride flag plastered somewhat randomly on the product. They claim that they are donating some of their profits to an LGBTQIA+ organisation but when I asked for specifics, they could not tell me which organisation.

Picture Credit: Sumaya Mamdoo

Launching a campaign takes months to plan. Proposals, organisations and the expected net profit should have been thought of before this launch. The lack of information of who in the LGBTQIA+ they are going to help indicates that this might just be another marketing tool for more money.

Along with the merchandise, Woolworths has said that they “have an internal W Pride team that will address issues faced by the LGBTQIA+ community” and “have adapted their working wardrobe policy to recognise everyone’s unique preferences.” They have also stated that they will not end the campaign due to the backlash and they position themselves as an ally. These statements now reflect that they are aligned with the movement and care about queer issues but there is no way to truly know. Do they have gender-neutral contract forms? What are the HR policies for when someone uses a slur related to sexual orientation?

Other gripes with this Woolworths collection are that there are no references to queer artists or designers and the items feature a very basic design. South African history saw gay rights apartheid activists organise the first South African pride in October of 1992 (also the first pride on the African continent) so why not launch this campaign then when most pride walks happen here anyway? Or honour those activists like Simon Nkoli. We see campaigns for Women’s Day in August here and not in correspondence with International Women’s Day. 

We should all look at the way inclusivity expresses itself in late-stage capitalism. Are we only included, recognised and validated when there is a product for us? Why does the exchange of money mean so much about who we are in the world? The same could be said for when no one could find the Bombay Crush Woolworths sold during Ramadan. Whether it is hatred or love, why is there so much passion for a conglomerate taking away your money in this current recession?
This is the first time we have seen a campaign like this from Woolworths, so we need time to make a proper judgement on whether this is pinkwashing or not. Whether or not you agree or belong to the queer community, I think we should all be more aware of how corporates market to everyone.
 

Subscribe now at only $10 / year  to become a member of our Covered Magazine Community and start redeeming your benefits immediately. Receive VIP access to our events or workshops, as well as incredible vouchers to treat yourself all year.

Access Our Vouchers  

Similar Posts